Visit our new blog. It lists all the new things that we are doing and what new material has been added to our site. We even list new missionaries who sign up with us for technical support so you can pray for them. FCM News
1One day as Jesus was standing by the Lake of Gennesaret, with
the people crowding around him and listening to the word of God,
2he saw at the water's edge two boats, left there by the fishermen,
who were washing their nets. 3He got into one of the boats, the
one belonging to Simon, and asked him to put out a little from
shore. Then he sat down and taught the people from the boat.
4When he had finished speaking, he said to Simon, "Put out
into deep water, and let down the nets for a catch."
5Simon answered, "Master, we've worked hard all night and
haven't caught anything. But because you say so, I will let down
the nets."
6When they had done so, they caught such a large number of fish
that their nets began to break. 7So they signaled their partners
in the other boat to come and help them, and they came and filled
both boats so full that they began to sink.
8When Simon Peter saw this, he fell at Jesus' knees and said, "Go
away from me, Lord; I am a sinful man!" 9For he and all his
companions were astonished at the catch of fish they had taken,
10and so were James and John, the sons of Zebedee, Simon's partners.
11Then Jesus said to Simon, "Don't be afraid; from now on
you will catch men." So they pulled their boats up on shore,
left everything and followed him.
The Man With Leprosy
12While Jesus was in one of the towns, a man came along who was
covered with leprosy. When he saw Jesus, he fell with his face
to the ground and begged him, "Lord, if you are willing, you
can make me clean."
13Jesus reached out his hand and touched the man. "I am willing," he
said. "Be clean!" And immediately the leprosy left him.
14Then Jesus ordered him, "Don't tell anyone, but go, show
yourself to the priest and offer the sacrifices that Moses commanded
for your cleansing, as a testimony to them."
15Yet the news about him spread all the more, so that crowds of
people came to hear him and to be healed of their sicknesses. 16But
Jesus often withdrew to lonely places and prayed.
Jesus Heals a Paralytic
17One day as he was teaching, Pharisees and teachers of the law,
who had come from every village of Galilee and from Judea and Jerusalem,
were sitting there. And the power of the Lord was present for him
to heal the sick. 18Some men came carrying a paralytic on a mat
and tried to take him into the house to lay him before Jesus. 19When
they could not find a way to do this because of the crowd, they
went up on the roof and lowered him on his mat through the tiles
into the middle of the crowd, right in front of Jesus.
20When Jesus saw their faith, he said, "Friend, your sins
are forgiven."
21The Pharisees and the teachers of the law began thinking to themselves, "Who
is this fellow who speaks blasphemy? Who can forgive sins but God
alone?"
22Jesus knew what they were thinking and asked, "Why are you
thinking these things in your hearts? 23Which is easier: to say,
'Your sins are forgiven,' or to say, 'Get up and walk'? 24But that
you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive
sins...." He said to the paralyzed man, "I tell you,
get up, take your mat and go home." 25Immediately he stood
up in front of them, took what he had been lying on and went home
praising God. 26Everyone was amazed and gave praise to God. They
were filled with awe and said, "We have seen remarkable things
today."
The Calling of Levi
27After this, Jesus went out and saw a tax collector by the name
of Levi sitting at his tax booth. "Follow me," Jesus
said to him, 28and Levi got up, left everything and followed him.
29Then Levi held a great banquet for Jesus at his house, and a
large crowd of tax collectors and others were eating with them.
30But the Pharisees and the teachers of the law who belonged to
their sect complained to his disciples, "Why do you eat and
drink with tax collectors and 'sinners'?"
31Jesus answered them, "It is not the healthy who need a doctor,
but the sick. 32I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners
to repentance."
Jesus Questioned About Fasting
33They said to him, "John's disciples often fast and pray,
and so do the disciples of the Pharisees, but yours go on eating
and drinking."
34Jesus answered, "Can you make the guests of the bridegroom
fast while he is with them? 35But the time will come when the bridegroom
will be taken from them; in those days they will fast."
36He told them this parable: "No one tears a patch from a
new garment and sews it on an old one. If he does, he will have
torn the new garment, and the patch from the new will not match
the old. 37And no one pours new wine into old wineskins. If he
does, the new wine will burst the skins, the wine will run out
and the wineskins will be ruined. 38No, new wine must be poured
into new wineskins. 39And no one after drinking old wine wants
the new, for he says, 'The old is better.' "
Luke 5:1-39
Explanation:
The Gathering of Disciples (5:1-6:16)
Jesus' gathering of disciples was not unusual in his time and
Jewish setting. Many rabbis would gather students around them to
teach Torah. But the kind of disciples Jesus gathers is unusual--they
are not theological professionals. Fishermen, tax collectors, former
revolutionaries and just plain old sinners make up this new community.
Jesus launches them on a journey with God, a walk in which God
begins to work in their lives. The lesson is that we need not be
perfect to come to God; rather, we need to trust God and let him
do his gracious work in transforming our lives.
The various "call scenes" that appear in this section
underline the nature of the new community (5:1-11, 27-39; 6:12-16).
It does not shun sinners, but invites them to come and meet God
and his healing forgiveness. Even the miracles of this section
show how much Jesus identifies with those he gathers to himself.
These unusual events underline the authority he has in creating
this new band of followers (5:12-16, 17-26; 6:1-5, 6-11).
The gathering of this unorthodox group of followers and the practices
they engage in heighten opposition. Jesus' ways are not the ways
of the Jewish leadership, nor are they the ways of a self-righteous
elitism. He attracts those who know that they need God and that
Jesus has the authority to forgive their sin (5:24, 31-32).
Come Work with Me: The Gathering of Disciples (5:1-11)
Besides teaching and miracles, Jesus' ministry centers on his
disciples. Luke 5:1-11 details how Jesus confirms the call of four
disciples to serve with him. In this passage, miracle, teaching
and discipleship form a collage that explains mission and who is
qualified for it.
Jesus performs a nature miracle, but the saying in verse 10 turns
the entire miracle into a picture of mission. Here event and symbol
merge. The event signifies not only what disciples are called to
do but who disciples are as they do it. Simon Peter and Jesus represent
different sides of the theology that undergirds the community Jesus
is forging. Simon, for his part, knows that he is a sinner who
is not worthy to experience the benefits of God's power and presence.
There is no presumption that God owes him anything. Jesus, exemplifying
God's grace, makes it clear that such a humble approach to God
is exactly what God will use. Jesus calls these fishermen to fish
for people rather than for finned water-dwellers. Luke presents
these two truths quite dramatically and vividly.
Jesus' preaching is popular, so he must ask Simon to let him teach
from his boat in the Lake of Gennesaret, better known as the Sea
of Galilee. If this is an average ancient fishing boat, it would
be twenty to thirty feet long (Stein 1992:169; Wachsmann 1988).
Much in this event is ironic. When Jesus tells Simon to put the
boat out and cast down his nets, it is a carpenter's son and teacher
telling a fisherman how to fish. It is a little like a pastor telling
a CEO how to run technical aspects of his business! Not only that,
but Simon's response makes it clear that conditions for fishing
are not right, since a major effort the night before had totally
failed. Yet despite appearances and against his professional judgment,
he follows the teacher's command to let down the nets. Simon Peter
is responsive to God's messenger and thus an example of faith.
The result is success and near disaster at the same time. The
nets are filled to overflowing, and so is the boat! The fisherman
is desperate for help to bring in all the fish. The boat is so
full it begins to sink. Jesus has guided Simon to a great catch,
but that catch is a picture of how he will guide the disciples
in other, more spiritual affairs.
Simon Peter realizes he has been brought into more than a successful
commercial venture. As nice as it would be to have Jesus as a permanent
fishing guide, God's messenger is in their midst, and the fisherman
knows enough about God's holiness to know he is at risk. So Simon
falls to his knees and confesses his unworthiness, asking Jesus
to depart. He understands that sin produces distance between himself
and God. Surely God wants nothing to do with a simple, sinful fisherman.
It is best that Jesus go. In fact, Jesus is addressed as "Lord," but
not because Peter understands that Jesus is God. It will take events
in the next few chapters to lead Simon to confess Jesus as Christ
(8:22-26; 9:18-20). Rather, Jesus is Lord here because he is God's
agent. Nonetheless, Jesus should go, for Simon Peter is not worthy
of the agent's presence.
The size of the catch tells Simon and his companions that this
event has been no accident. The greatest moment in their fishing
career causes them to stop and ponder what God is doing. Jesus
has taken Peter's humble faith and scared him to death with God's
presence. But in the uncertainty that often surrounds faith comes
the divine honoring of its presence and a calm voice that says, "Don't
be afraid." Grace is active. Simon Peter, James and John learn
that God will take the faith of humble fishermen and ask them to
join him in catching other people for God.
Simon Peter represents all disciples. His humility and awareness
of his sin do not disqualify him from service; they are the prerequisite
for service. Simon's response recalls the reaction of earlier great
servants of God like Isaiah and Jeremiah, who also bowed low in
humility when they caught a glimpse of God's presence (Is 6; Jer
1:1-10). Jesus does not call those who think they can help God
do his work. God does not need or want servants who think they
are doing God a favor. Jesus calls those who know they need to
be humble before his power and presence. From now on Simon will
be casting his nets in a different sea, the sea of humanity's need
for God.
A genuine meeting with Jesus alters one's perspective. An encounter
with God's power is no reason to draw back from him, but an opportunity
to approach him on the right basis, in faith and dependence. In
catching fish, Jesus has caught Simon Peter.
The mission is to catch persons alive. The figure involves rescue
from danger, since those caught are caught alive (on the term "alive," see
Num 31:15, 18; Deut 20:16; Josh 2:13; 2 Maccabees 12:35; on the "fisher" and
being hooked, Jer 16:16; Ezek 29:4-6; Amos 4:2; Hab 1:14-17). In
the Old Testament this kind of symbolism is usually negative, but
for Jesus it is clearly positive.
The response is instantaneous and total. When the boats come in,
the former fishermen leave everything behind and follow Jesus.
The call had gone to Peter in verse 10, but all those who experience
the catch follow Jesus. The fishing expedition has brought in its
first catch. Sinners are transformed into servants of God. That
is how great God's holiness and grace can be.
The Cleansing of the Leper (5:12-16)
If the call of the disciples shows Jesus reaching out to sinners,
his healing of the leper shows that Jesus is also concerned for
the total outcast. For a modern parallel to the leper, we may think
of victims of AIDS. Just like the AIDS victim, the leper of the
ancient world was ostracized from society and largely forgotten.
True, today the victims of AIDS get much publicity, along with
a great clamor to fund research to fight the HIV disease, but many
people would prefer to forget these victims of disease and shunt
them off to the fringes of society. To get close to them or touch
them would be to risk too much.
I think of an attempt to launch a cooperative ministry to AIDS
patients in my area. Many churches responded that the goal was
admirable and they would offer moral support, but what would they
do if AIDS patients came to faith and wanted to come into their
church? The risk was too great, so they opted out of supporting
the effort directly.
I wonder if Jesus would have responded this way. Jesus said he
came to minister to those in need, and Luke 5:12-16 shows how that
ministry extends to the very bottom rungs of the social ladder.
No one is beyond the potential touch of Jesus' love.
Luke narrates this miracle with extreme economy. Jesus is in one
of the towns. The leper humbly implores Jesus to help him, confident
that if Jesus wills it, Jesus can make him clean. Clearly, word
about Jesus had spread even to these marginal colonies in the society.
Make me clean, though literal, suggests a real cleansing of the
person (remember, all the miracles in this Gospel have a "picture" element).
The leper knows Jesus' capability, but he is uncertain of the extent
of his compassion. The extent of Jesus' compassion is revealed
here. In the modern world it is perhaps the exact reverse. Today's
person on the street does not doubt Jesus' compassion but does
question his capability. Accounts like this demonstrate that Jesus
opened himself to all.
Jesus' touching the leper is significant, since such contact rendered
him ceremonially unclean (Lev 13:42-46; all of m. Nega`im). The
physical communication of charity meant suffering ceremonial uncleanness
that could affect his involvement in corporate worship. Given that
Jesus' other miracles have occurred through the mere speaking of
his word, it's clear that the act of touching is conscious. The
healing is immediate; the compassion is demonstrable. Jesus is
able and willing.
Jesus tells the healed leper to show [himself] to the priest,
which fits with the command of Leviticus 14:1-32 about dealing
with healing from leprosy. Beyond this, however, the healed man
should keep silence about what has happened. This part of Jesus'
instructions is perplexing. We would think Jesus would appreciate
the public relations coup such a healing represents. Think of how
we broadcast even the claim of such events today. The contrast
is significant.
There are various explanations for the silence. One part of the
explanation seems to be that Jesus wants to quell excessive excitement
about his healing ministry so that the message he brings does not
get lost in a flurry of requests for miracles. It may also be that
the man is to keep silent only until the priest formally declares
him clean. Regardless, it is clear that Jesus approaches his ministry
of miracles circumspectly (Mk 8:11-13; Jn 6:26-27). Perhaps because
the miracles are pictures of deeper realities, he wants people
not to be overcome by their more obvious, surface meaning--a tendency
that proves hard to avoid.
The instruction to go to the priests serves as a testimony to
them. Is them a reference to the priests or to all people? The
stress on obeying the Torah suggests that those who receive the
testimony are the priests. In the next event Luke explains that
the Jewish leadership is present, so clearly the testimony gets
their attention. As 7:22 makes clear, the cleansing of lepers is
a sign that "the time of fulfillment" has come.
Word does spread. Crowds gather (v. 15). Luke 4:44 is being fulfilled.
Mark 1:45 notes that the crowd is growing to crushing levels. Nevertheless,
Jesus periodically withdraws to collect himself and commune with
God (v. 16). Seeking time with God is key to ministering effectively.
In fact, numerous conflicts follow in Luke, so the Gospel writer
is making it clear that before Jesus meets with trouble, he communes
with God.
Sometimes reaching out to outcasts is unpopular. Sometimes conflict
for doing so is not a sign of failure.
The Healing of the Paralytic and the Authority to Forgive Sin
(5:17-26)
Luke narrates yet another miracle, the healing of the paralytic.
This miracle is significant for five reasons. First, it shows that
Jesus' authority extends even to the forgiveness of sins. Second,
the entire affair is witnessed by the Jewish leaders, the Pharisees
and the scribes. They make an instant theological assessment and
recognize that Jesus is making unique claims--claims that are blasphemous
if they are not true. Third, this is the first time God vindicates
Jesus' claims during his ministry. Later Judaism would teach that
God does not help sinners or liars (t. Nedarim 41a), so if Jesus
is not who he claims to be, then this man should not walk away
healed. The fact that the paralytic walks away healed means that
some type of transcendent power operates through Jesus. Later Luke
reveals the debate over what or who that power is (11:14-23). Fourth,
the miracle pictures what Jesus can do for people. The paralytic
is stationary and totally helpless. But after his healing, he can
walk through life and praise God. Finally, the text shows the importance
of faith. It is the faith of those who bring the paralytic to Jesus
that is highlighted. This detail seems to indicate that God honors
us as we seek to lead others to the Lord.
Though Mark 2:1 mentions that this event takes place in Capernaum,
Luke simply tells the story. The presence of Pharisees and teachers
of the law shows that word about Jesus has spread to the upper
echelons of the Jewish faith. The Pharisees were a nonpriestly,
lay separatist movement whose goal was to keep the nation faithful
to God. Their name is probably a transcription of an Aramaic term
meaning "separated ones" (Fitzmyer 1981:581). To prevent
violations of the Mosaic law, they developed an elaborate system
of traditions to codify practice (Meyer 1974:11-48; Josephus Antiquities
13.5.9 171; 13.10.5-6 288-98; 17.2.4 41-45; 18.1.2 11; Jewish Wars
2.8.14 162-63). They desired to "build a fence around the
law" to prevent it from being violated (Pirqe `Abot 1:1).
The teachers of the law, also known as the scribes (v. 21), helped
to study legal questions and develop the tradition (Jeremias 1964c:740-42;
Rengstorf 1964:159). The word sometimes translated "scribes" has
roots in the postexilic period to refer to one learned in matters
of the law (Ezra 7:6, 11; Neh 8:1). Luke reveals that these leaders
have come from as far away as Jerusalem.
In the midst of such traditional religious authorities, God's
power rests on Jesus. He has the power of the Lord . . . to heal
the sick. Luke is going to great pains to indicate that Jesus did
not require official endorsement from the Jewish hierarchy. His
commission was unique, coming directly from God, as his baptism
had made clear (see 20:1-8).
The paralytic comes on a mat (kline, Luke and Matthew) or a pallet
(krabbaton, Mark). But the crowds prevent access, so the friends
must scale the ladder on the side of the house to get up on the
roof, where they can cut through the roof and lower the man in
front of Jesus. Needless to say, such activity is highly distracting.
The man ends up right in front of Jesus. So now the Teacher must
act. What will he do?
Jesus pulls a surprise. No doubt the crowd has expected a healing,
since Jesus' reputation has spread far and wide already (4:40-44).
But instead Jesus talks about sin. And thus again a miracle becomes
a parable. This time it pictures the presence of the destructive
forces of sin in the world. This man is a painting of the effects
of the Fall. Such a linkage is not surprising in a Jewish setting
(1 Maccabees 9:54-56; 2 Maccabees 3:22-28; 3 Maccabees 2:21-22;
Jn 9:2-3). Jesus claims to have the authority to reverse those
effects, so he says, "Friend, your sins are forgiven." This
theme is frequent in Luke (5:29-32; 7:34, 36-50; 15:3-7, 11-32;
18:10-14; 19:8-10; 23:40-43).
The remark elicits an instant theological critique from the religious
experts present. They began thinking to themselves, "Who is
this fellow who speaks blasphemy? Who can forgive sins but God
alone?" The Pharisees get high marks for perceiving the theological
significance of Jesus' statement. They see the stakes correctly.
They understand how great Jesus' claim is. The issue of blasphemy
will become a central concern at Jesus' trial, as Jesus reiterates
an authority for himself there that the leadership will question
(22:67-71). To blaspheme was to perform an action that violated
God's majesty. Claiming a prerogative that was only God's would
be such a violation. So the issue raised by the act and its proclamation
is authority pure and simple. Jesus has implied the same authority
in Luke 4:18. In his own eyes, Jesus is more than a teacher of
ethics.
It seems likely that the Pharisees' musings are private, because
the text goes on to note that Jesus knew what they were thinking.
Usually when Jesus is reading someone's thoughts, a rebuke or challenge
follows. Such is the case here.
Jesus poses a conundrum: "Which is easier: to say, `Your
sins are forgiven,' or to say, `Get up and walk'?" Now there
is irony here. It is easier to say sin is forgiven, since one cannot
see it. But actually to forgive sin is the harder thing to do.
Still, the healing of a lame man could be corroborated visually;
one could see its success immediately. Jesus' remarks, however,
link the two actions. Healing will reveal the authority to forgive--and
in the process raise many questions about who Jesus is. So Jesus
says, "But that you might know that the Son of Man has authority
on earth to forgive sins . . . I tell you, get up, take your mat
and go home." This moment in the account calls to mind the
modern sports expression "crunch time." Either the man
gets up and walks or he continues to lie there. Either Jesus' claim
comes through, or he is utterly embarrassed. God does not help
sinners, so what will happen? Jesus has put theological stakes
on the event. Will God vindicate him?
This text is important for another reason. It is the first time
Luke uses the important expression Son of Man. Later in this Gospel
it is clear that he is using the term as a title. In Aramaic this
phrase was an idiom that either meant "someone" or served
as a roundabout way to refer to oneself. Be aware that at this
point the Old Testament background for this term has not yet been
revealed. Jesus will do that later in his ministry when he ties
the title to imagery from Daniel 7:13-14. All son of man meant
to the audience here was "some human being." But of course,
the moment Jesus forgives and heals the paralyzed man, Son of Man
becomes a very specific reference to him, since the authority he
is claiming is not generic to all humans but is his alone.
In sum, Jesus' claim to have special authority and so to be a
unique human being is the issue of the passage. The beauty of Jesus'
use of this idiom alongside his action is that it allows him to
raise a question about his identity in terms that honor both his
unique authority and his humanity. The claim, however, rides on
what the paralytic does in the next few moments.
Immediately he stood up in front of them. The man's walk means
God has talked! As the former paralytic praises God, amazement
overwhelms the crowd. They have seen remarkable things. The Greek
term used here is paradoxa, a word from which we get our word "paradox." But
in Greek the term simply refers to unusual events. Again Luke ends
the passage asking the reader implicitly to ponder what has taken
place. What happened? What has been claimed about what happened?
Events speak louder than words (7:18-23): the Son of Man has authority
to forgive sins.
Jesus has just painted a picture that speaks more than a library
full of books on Christology. He has backed up his words with action.
God is vindicating Jesus' claims. At crunch time Jesus applies
his authority with great skill. As the paralytic walks, the question
becomes who will walk with him and share the forgiveness Jesus
has pictured. Fence-sitting is no longer possible, given the nature
of Jesus' claims.
The Calling of Levi (5:27-32)
Again Jesus' attention turns to a social outcast, in this case
Levi the tax collector. Luke has already discussed tax collectors
when he described the ministry of John the Baptist (see 3:10-14).
Jesus initiates relationships with outcasts, even though pious
people in Israel challenge such associations (7:36-50; 15:1-2;
19:1-10). As the earlier account with Peter showed (5:1-11), Jesus
calls sinners to righteousness and to share in mission with him.
Jesus does not merely forgive sinners, he openly associates with
them.
But why? Why does Jesus associate with sinners when so many righteous
people do not want to have anything to do with them? Many people
think one must choose absolute separation if one is to remain pure,
but for Jesus this is a false choice. Jesus views people in terms
of what God could make them into, rather than pigeonholing them
into who they currently are. There is no compromise with holiness
in his relationships with sinners, because one of the very characteristics
of God's holiness is the way he reaches out in mercy to those in
need (1:46-53). God graciously takes the sinner who is responsive
to him and begins the work of transformation.
The story in this passage proceeds simply. Jesus observes the
tax collector Levi at work and calls him to follow (9:23, 59; 18:22).
Levi's response is total--he got up, left everything and followed
him. The instantaneous and comprehensive nature of the decision
to join Jesus shows both the reputation Jesus has and the quality
of an exemplary response to Jesus. Levi has put Jesus first. To
follow him is a priority.
In fact, Levi wishes to celebrate by introducing Jesus to his
friends. Such is often the case with recent converts to Jesus.
Unchurched friends are often the first to hear about the new discovery.
So it should be. The tragedy is that after people have been in
the church for a time, they find it hard to relate to outsiders.
Jesus does not suffer from this problem; he consciously makes an
effort to associate with those outside his community. He does not
run or hide from the world in need, but engages with it realistically
so its real needs can be addressed. Often what wins an outsider
to God is a genuine friendship. Despite Levi's low social status,
he feels free to associate with Jesus. Jesus' invitation has made
that clear.
A contrasting attitude emerges in the grumbling among Jewish leaders.
Their commitment to purity, their sense of what God requires of
them and their fear of risking exposure to the world cause them
to shun outsiders and criticize those who try to relate in a healthy
and engaging way to sinners. Table fellowship in the ancient world
meant mutual acceptance. So at stake in the Pharisees and scribes'
response is a worldview question. Should we really get close to
the socially objectionable, to people like tax collectors and sinners?
The Greek word used for their complaint, egongyzon, is significant
because it is the term Numbers 14:26-35 LXX uses to describe the
nation's grumbling to God in the wilderness. This word sounds like
its meaning; we can almost hear the harsh tone of voice as we read
the words (7:34 repeats the complaint).
Jesus' reply makes it clear that recovery, not quarantine, is
the message of his ministry. Jesus pictures himself as a doctor
who treats the sick, not the strong. The remark takes the Pharisees'
perspective, though it does not endorse their righteousness. Jesus'
point is that those who know they need help will respond to the
Physician. Often the unrighteous are aware of their need, whereas
the unrighteous "righteous" are not. The unrighteous
need a breath of potential acceptance and a whiff of God's grace
to open up to his work. The appeal to physician imagery is common
in Judaism (Is 3:7; Jer 8:22; esp. Sirach 38:1-15; Bovon 1989:259,
n. 24).
Jesus' second point is a mission statement that explains why he
seeks the outsider. This is one of several such mission statements
in Luke (7:34; 12:49, 51; 18:8; 19:10). Jesus has come to minister
to those who have need of repentance. He calls to them to repent.
Repentance is a major Lukan theme, and only Luke mentions it in
this scene (3:3, 8; 13:1-5; 15:7-10; 16:30; 17:3-4; 24:47). Here
Jesus offers a picture of true repentance: it is like going to
a doctor for help. The "cure," if it is to come, must
come from outside of oneself. A repentant heart is open to God
and to his administering the necessary medicine for life. God graciously
gives this medicine to those who seek forgiveness through him.
Jesus sees opportunity for restoration for sinners and works to
achieve relationship with them so they can experience the healing
they need. When tax collectors and sinners come to the table in
the clinic, Jesus, the Great Physician, is not about to turn them
away. As in the other events chronicled in Luke 4:31--5:32, Jesus
reaches out to all types of needy people. All can benefit from
the power of his healing presence.
Some are still uncomfortable with such an open ministry, but this
is evangelism in its most authentic form. Jesus' ministry is about
compassion and grace. When Jesus proclaims God's love, the outsider
knows Jesus means it. Both his words and his actions show it. In
his openness Jesus risks criticism and ridicule. But given that
Jesus pursues such contacts with gusto, can his disciples do otherwise?
Why Are You Different? Part 1 (5:33-39)
People have trouble accepting those who are different. When someone
marches to the beat of a different drum, we are forced to ask questions
about them and ourselves. Jesus' outreach to sinners was a different
way of doing things, and so was his approach to traditional customs
of piety.
Finally the Pharisees get up the nerve to ask why Jesus' disciples
do things differently. Of course, they are really asking about
Jesus. He is their major concern. When it comes to ascetic practices
like fasting, Jesus is not like the Pharisees, or even like his
forerunner John the Baptist. So Jesus' meal with sinners is not
the only thing that bothers the leadership. He hangs out with outsiders
and he does not follow the usual practices of piety. Why is that?
Specifically, they ask him about fasting and prayer. The ancient
practice of fasting had a rich heritage in Judaism. It was a highly
regarded act of worship. The Day of Atonement was celebrated with
a fast (Lev 16:29, 31). A four-day fast commemorated the fall of
Jerusalem (Zech 7:3, 5; 8:19). Fasts could be acts of penitence
(1 Kings 21:27; Joel 1:14; Is 58:1-9) or could be associated with
mourning (Esther 4:3). Pharisees fasted twice a week, on Monday
and Thursday (8:12; Didache 8:1; Behm 1967a:924-35). Fasts are
serious expressions of worship.
Jesus' reply not only explains why his community does not engage
in such practice but makes an additional point about what his presence
represents. Jesus' simple answer is that now is the time not for
fasting but for celebration. He compares himself to a bridegroom
at the time of his wedding. His presence marks the beginning of
a new era. You do not fast at a wedding! The marital imagery pictures
God's relationship to his people in the Old Testament and in later
Judaism (Is 54:5-6; 62:4-5; Jer 2:2; Ezek 16; Hos 2:14-23; 4 Ezra
2:15-41). But nowhere in Judaism do we have the image of the Messiah
as bridegroom. The New Testament uses this imagery often (Mt 22:2,
25:1; Lk 12:35-36; Eph 5:22-33; Rev 19:7; 21:2). Jesus is saying
that the present is a special time to celebrate the arrival of
a new point in God's plan. Later, when the bridegroom is removed
(4 Ezra 10:1-4), there will be time to fast. This reference to
removal is Jesus' first hint that rejection will come. Then there
will be need for reflection and fasting. People will long for the
ultimate redemption that the bridegroom's initial arrival promised
(Rom 8:17-30; 1 Cor 15:20-28; Rev). Jesus does not regulate or
legislate fasting. He says simply that it will become appropriate
again.
But Jesus does not stop there. He drives home the point that his
presence represents something new in God's plan, calling for a
new way of ordering the spiritual life. Luke 5:36-39 gives three
pictures, what Luke calls a parable (parabole), to make the point.
Jesus is like a new piece of cloth. No seamstress worth her salt
would take a new piece of cloth and patch it onto an old garment.
Such a match produces two problems. The new cloth will tear the
old, and the pieces of material will not match. There is irony
here: the patch that is supposed to fix the garment would end up
ruining both. This new era Jesus brings simply cannot be wed to
the old practices. It is new and requires new ways.
The second picture involves wine and wineskins. In the first century,
wineskins would have been made of goatskin or sheepskin taken from
the neck area of the animal (Gen 21:14-15; 19; Ps 119:83). Again,
the result of putting new wine into old skins would be disaster,
a tragic waste of wine. The new wine would ferment and cause the
old wineskins to burst--the new wine would then be lost and the
wineskin rendered useless.
There can be no syncretism between what Jesus brings and the old
tradition of Judaism. If it were tried, both would be destroyed.
Jesus brings a new era and a fresh approach to God that cannot
be mixed with the old traditions. In many ways the book of Acts
is the historical outworking of this point. The gospel is a new
way, so the practices of Judaism cannot contain it. This is why
Luke will later call Jesus a prophet like Moses (Lk 9:35; Acts
3:12-26; see Deut 18:15). Jesus, like Moses, is the leader-prophet
of a freshly formed community of God, revealing the new ways the
new movement requires.
So new wine must be poured into new wineskins. Jesus' presence
requires a new way, new forms and a new spirit. Even when fasting
continues after the bridegroom is gone, it will be different. It
will always be done in hope of his return.
Next Jesus faces the possibility of rejection. His third picture
involves someone satisfied with the old wine: "No one after
drinking old wine wants the new, for he says, `The old is better.' " This
is probably a warning and an explanation. Jesus knows that some,
especially among the Pharisees, will not come to him, because they
are satisfied with the wine they have. Nothing will change their
mind. Rejection by some is inevitable. Jesus' presence means a
choice between him and the old style of Judaism. With Jesus' presence
things are different. To mark the difference, Jesus does not fast.
New times require fresh ways.
Jesus does not specify here exactly what makes his way new. The
association with practices of eating and fasting suggests that
piety motivated by law and tradition may well be in view. The new
dynamic Jesus brings will rely on the Spirit of God (Acts 10:34-43;
15:1-21). Things done merely for the sake of tradition will not
be persuasive anymore. Jesus' new way brings freshness and a dynamic,
responsive quality to our walk with God.